Planning for retirement can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re faced with countless investment options and conflicting advice. Two popular approaches stand out: target date funds (which automatically adjust your investments over time) and building your own DIY portfolio (where you pick and manage individual funds yourself).
Both strategies can help you build wealth for retirement, but they work very differently. Target date funds offer simplicity and professional management, while DIY portfolios give you complete control over your investments. The right choice depends on your knowledge, time availability, and personal preferences.
In this guide, we’ll break down exactly how each approach works, compare their costs and benefits, and help you decide which strategy fits your retirement goals.
What Are Target Date Funds?
Target date funds are professionally managed investment funds designed to automatically adjust your portfolio as you approach retirement. You simply choose a fund with a date close to when you plan to retire — like “Target Date 2050” if you’re aiming to retire around 2050.
The fund starts with an aggressive mix of investments (typically 90% stocks, 10% bonds) when you’re young, then gradually shifts to more conservative investments (more bonds, fewer stocks) as your target date approaches. This process is called the “glide path.”
For example, a Target Date 2030 fund might currently hold 60% stocks and 40% bonds since retirement is approaching, while a Target Date 2055 fund might hold 90% stocks and 10% bonds since there’s more time to ride out market volatility.
Most major investment companies offer target date funds, including Vanguard, Fidelity, and Charles Schwab. You can typically invest in these through your workplace 401(k) or in personal retirement accounts like IRAs.
Building a DIY Investment Portfolio
A DIY portfolio means you personally select and manage individual mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), or other investments. Instead of buying one target date fund, you might choose three separate funds: a US stock fund, an international stock fund, and a bond fund.
You decide how much money goes into each fund based on your age, risk tolerance, and investment goals. For instance, a 30-year-old might allocate 70% to US stocks, 20% to international stocks, and 10% to bonds.
With a DIY approach, you’re responsible for rebalancing your portfolio — selling some investments and buying others to maintain your desired allocation. You might do this annually or when your allocations drift significantly from your target.
Popular DIY portfolio strategies include the three-fund portfolio (US stocks, international stocks, bonds) or more complex approaches with additional asset classes like real estate investment trusts (REITs) or emerging market funds.
Cost Comparison: Fees Matter Over Time
Investment fees might seem small, but they compound significantly over decades of retirement saving. Here’s how target date funds and DIY portfolios typically compare:
| Investment Approach | Typical Annual Fee | Cost on $100,000 | Cost on $500,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target Date Fund | 0.10% – 0.75% | $100 – $750 | $500 – $3,750 |
| DIY Portfolio (Low-cost funds) | 0.03% – 0.20% | $30 – $200 | $150 – $1,000 |
| DIY Portfolio (High-cost funds) | 0.50% – 1.50% | $500 – $1,500 | $2,500 – $7,500 |
Low-cost target date funds from companies like Vanguard or Fidelity typically charge between 0.10% and 0.15% annually. However, some target date funds charge 0.75% or more, especially those offered through certain workplace plans.
DIY portfolios can be extremely cost-effective if you choose low-cost index funds. You might pay just 0.03% to 0.05% per fund, resulting in total portfolio costs well under 0.20% annually. However, if you select actively managed funds, costs can exceed those of target date funds.
The key is comparing specific funds, not just approaches. A low-cost target date fund often beats a high-cost DIY portfolio.
Control and Customization Differences
Target date funds offer limited customization. You can’t adjust the stock-to-bond ratio or exclude certain investments you dislike. The fund company makes all allocation decisions based on their glide path formula.
This lack of control can be problematic if you disagree with the fund’s strategy. For example, maybe you want more international exposure than the target date fund provides, or you prefer a more aggressive allocation as you approach retirement.
DIY portfolios give you complete control. You can:
– Choose your exact asset allocation
– Exclude investments that don’t align with your values
– Adjust your strategy based on market conditions or personal circumstances
– Add specialized investments like REITs or commodities
– Maintain a more aggressive or conservative approach than typical for your age
However, this control comes with responsibility. You must make informed decisions about asset allocation, fund selection, and rebalancing frequency. Poor choices can significantly impact your retirement savings.
Time and Complexity Considerations
Target date funds are designed for hands-off investing. Once you choose a fund and set up automatic contributions, you can essentially ignore your investments for years. The fund automatically rebalances and adjusts your allocation as you age.
This simplicity makes target date funds ideal for busy people or those who find investing stressful. You don’t need to research asset allocation strategies, compare fund performance, or remember to rebalance your portfolio.
DIY portfolios require ongoing attention and decision-making. You’ll need to:
– Research and select appropriate funds
– Determine your initial asset allocation
– Monitor your portfolio’s performance
– Rebalance periodically (typically annually)
– Adjust your allocation as you age
– Stay informed about market conditions and investment strategies
The time commitment isn’t enormous — perhaps a few hours per year for basic maintenance. However, many investors spend much more time researching strategies, analyzing performance, and fine-tuning their portfolios.
Performance and Risk Trade-offs
Target date funds aim for “average” performance appropriate for your age group. They won’t beat the market, but they shouldn’t dramatically underperform either. The professional management and automatic rebalancing help prevent common investor mistakes like buying high and selling low.
However, target date funds from different companies can have surprisingly different allocations and performance. According to research from the Federal Reserve, target date funds with the same target year can have stock allocations that differ by 20-30 percentage points.
DIY portfolios can potentially outperform target date funds if you make smart choices and stick to your strategy. You might achieve lower costs, better tax efficiency, or superior asset allocation for your specific situation.
The risk is that DIY investors often make costly mistakes. Common errors include:
– Chasing hot investment trends
– Panicking and selling during market downturns
– Failing to rebalance regularly
– Taking on too much or too little risk
– Paying high fees for actively managed funds
Studies consistently show that the average investor underperforms the market, largely due to poor timing and emotional decision-making.
Tax Efficiency Considerations
In taxable investment accounts, DIY portfolios often provide better tax efficiency. You can use tax-loss harvesting (selling losing investments to offset gains), choose tax-efficient funds, and control when you realize capital gains.
Target date funds may generate taxable distributions even when you don’t sell shares, as the fund rebalances and adjusts its holdings. You have no control over the timing or amount of these distributions.
However, this tax advantage only applies to taxable accounts. In tax-advantaged retirement accounts like 401(k)s and IRAs, both approaches are equally tax-efficient since you don’t pay taxes on gains until withdrawal.
For most people, the majority of retirement savings occurs in tax-advantaged accounts, making this consideration less important than it might initially seem.
When to Choose Each Strategy
Target date funds work best if you:
– Want simple, hands-off investing
– Have limited investment knowledge or experience
– Don’t want to spend time managing your portfolio
– Are comfortable with “average” market returns
– Have access to low-cost target date funds
Consider a DIY portfolio if you:
– Enjoy researching and managing investments
– Want complete control over your asset allocation
– Have strong knowledge of investment principles
– Can stick to a long-term strategy without emotional reactions
– Have access to very low-cost index funds
– Want to optimize for tax efficiency in taxable accounts
Many successful investors use hybrid approaches. For example, you might use a target date fund in your 401(k) for simplicity, while building a more customized DIY portfolio in your IRA where you have broader fund choices.
Conclusion
Target date fund vs DIY portfolio retirement planning isn’t an all-or-nothing decision. Target date funds excel at simplicity and preventing investor mistakes, while DIY portfolios offer control and potentially lower costs. The “best” choice depends on your knowledge, time availability, and investment preferences.
If you’re new to investing or want hands-off simplicity, start with a low-cost target date fund — you can always switch to a DIY approach as your knowledge grows. If you’re comfortable with investment research and want maximum control, a DIY portfolio using low-cost index funds can be highly effective.
Remember that consistency matters more than perfection. Whether you choose target date funds or build your own portfolio, the most important step is starting early and contributing regularly. Both approaches can successfully build wealth for retirement when implemented properly.
The key is choosing a strategy you’ll stick with for decades, avoiding high fees, and not letting perfect be the enemy of good when it comes to your retirement planning.
Next read: Ready to put your retirement plan into action? Learn how much you should save each month: /retirement-savings-calculator